Currently, the prevalence of online handwriting has spurred a critical need for effective retrieval systems to accurately search relevant handwriting instances from specific writers, known as online writer retrieval. Despite the growing demand, this field suffers from a scarcity of well-established methodologies and public large-scale datasets. This paper tackles these challenges with a focus on Chinese handwritten phrases. First, we propose DOLPHIN, a novel retrieval model designed to enhance handwriting representations through synergistic temporal-frequency analysis. For frequency feature learning, we propose the HFGA block, which performs gated cross-attention between the vanilla temporal handwriting sequence and its high-frequency sub-bands to amplify salient writing details. For temporal feature learning, we propose the CAIR block, tailored to promote channel interaction and reduce channel redundancy. Second, to address data deficit, we introduce OLIWER, a large-scale online writer retrieval dataset encompassing over 670,000 Chinese handwritten phrases from 1,731 individuals. Through extensive evaluations, we demonstrate the superior performance of DOLPHIN over existing methods. In addition, we explore cross-domain writer retrieval and reveal the pivotal role of increasing feature alignment in bridging the distributional gap between different handwriting data. Our findings emphasize the significance of point sampling frequency and pressure features in improving handwriting representation quality and retrieval performance. Code and dataset are available at https://github.com/SCUT-DLVCLab/DOLPHIN.
While methods based on Vision Transformers (ViT) have achieved state-of-the-art performance in many domains, they have not yet been applied successfully in the domain of writer retrieval. The field is dominated by methods using handcrafted features or features extracted from Convolutional Neural Networks. In this work, we bridge this gap and present a novel method that extracts features from a ViT and aggregates them using VLAD encoding. The model is trained in a self-supervised fashion without any need for labels. We show that extracting local foreground features is superior to using the ViT's class token in the context of writer retrieval. We evaluate our method on two historical document collections. We set a new state-at-of-art performance on the Historical-WI dataset (83.1\% mAP), and the HisIR19 dataset (95.0\% mAP). Additionally, we demonstrate that our ViT feature extractor can be directly applied to modern datasets such as the CVL database (98.6\% mAP) without any fine-tuning.
This paper presents a character-based approach for enhancing writer retrieval performance in the context of Greek papyri. Our contribution lies in introducing character-level annotations for frequently used characters, in our case the trigram kai and four additional letters (epsilon, kappa, mu, omega), in Greek texts. We use a state-of-the-art writer retrieval approach based on NetVLAD and compare a character-level-based feature aggregation method against the current default baseline of using small patches located at SIFT keypoint locations for building the page descriptors. We demonstrate that by using only about 15 characters per page, we are able to boost the performance up to 4% mAP (a relative improvement of 11%) on the GRK-120 dataset. Additionally, our qualitative analysis offers insights into the similarity scores of SIFT patches and specific characters. We publish the dataset with character-level annotations, including a quality label and our binarized images for further research.
This paper introduces SAGHOG, a self-supervised pretraining strategy for writer retrieval using HOG features of the binarized input image. Our preprocessing involves the application of the Segment Anything technique to extract handwriting from various datasets, ending up with about 24k documents, followed by training a vision transformer on reconstructing masked patches of the handwriting. SAGHOG is then finetuned by appending NetRVLAD as an encoding layer to the pretrained encoder. Evaluation of our approach on three historical datasets, Historical-WI, HisFrag20, and GRK-Papyri, demonstrates the effectiveness of SAGHOG for writer retrieval. Additionally, we provide ablation studies on our architecture and evaluate un- and supervised finetuning. Notably, on HisFrag20, SAGHOG outperforms related work with a mAP of 57.2 % - a margin of 11.6 % to the current state of the art, showcasing its robustness on challenging data, and is competitive on even small datasets, e.g. GRK-Papyri, where we achieve a Top-1 accuracy of 58.0%.
This paper proposes a deep-learning-based approach to writer retrieval and identification for papyri, with a focus on identifying fragments associated with a specific writer and those corresponding to the same image. We present a novel neural network architecture that combines a residual backbone with a feature mixing stage to improve retrieval performance, and the final descriptor is derived from a projection layer. The methodology is evaluated on two benchmarks: PapyRow, where we achieve a mAP of 26.6 % and 24.9 % on writer and page retrieval, and HisFragIR20, showing state-of-the-art performance (44.0 % and 29.3 % mAP). Furthermore, our network has an accuracy of 28.7 % for writer identification. Additionally, we conduct experiments on the influence of two binarization techniques on fragments and show that binarizing does not enhance performance. Our code and models are available to the community.
This paper presents an unsupervised approach for writer retrieval based on clustering SIFT descriptors detected at keypoint locations resulting in pseudo-cluster labels. With those cluster labels, a residual network followed by our proposed NetRVLAD, an encoding layer with reduced complexity compared to NetVLAD, is trained on 32x32 patches at keypoint locations. Additionally, we suggest a graph-based reranking algorithm called SGR to exploit similarities of the page embeddings to boost the retrieval performance. Our approach is evaluated on two historical datasets (Historical-WI and HisIR19). We include an evaluation of different backbones and NetRVLAD. It competes with related work on historical datasets without using explicit encodings. We set a new State-of-the-art on both datasets by applying our reranking scheme and show that our approach achieves comparable performance on a modern dataset as well.
In this work, we explore massive pre-training on synthetic word images for enhancing the performance on four benchmark downstream handwriting analysis tasks. To this end, we build a large synthetic dataset of word images rendered in several handwriting fonts, which offers a complete supervision signal. We use it to train a simple convolutional neural network (ConvNet) with a fully supervised objective. The vector representations of the images obtained from the pre-trained ConvNet can then be considered as encodings of the handwriting style. We exploit such representations for Writer Retrieval, Writer Identification, Writer Verification, and Writer Classification and demonstrate that our pre-training strategy allows extracting rich representations of the writers' style that enable the aforementioned tasks with competitive results with respect to task-specific State-of-the-Art approaches.
Text-to-Image synthesis is the task of generating an image according to a specific text description. Generative Adversarial Networks have been considered the standard method for image synthesis virtually since their introduction. Denoising Diffusion Probabilistic Models are recently setting a new baseline, with remarkable results in Text-to-Image synthesis, among other fields. Aside its usefulness per se, it can also be particularly relevant as a tool for data augmentation to aid training models for other document image processing tasks. In this work, we present a latent diffusion-based method for styled text-to-text-content-image generation on word-level. Our proposed method is able to generate realistic word image samples from different writer styles, by using class index styles and text content prompts without the need of adversarial training, writer recognition, or text recognition. We gauge system performance with the Fr\'echet Inception Distance, writer recognition accuracy, and writer retrieval. We show that the proposed model produces samples that are aesthetically pleasing, help boosting text recognition performance, and get similar writer retrieval score as real data. Code is available at: https://github.com/koninik/WordStylist.
The analysis of digitized historical manuscripts is typically addressed by paleographic experts. Writer identification refers to the classification of known writers while writer retrieval seeks to find the writer by means of image similarity in a dataset of images. While automatic writer identification/retrieval methods already provide promising results for many historical document types, papyri data is very challenging due to the fiber structures and severe artifacts. Thus, an important step for an improved writer identification is the preprocessing and feature sampling process. We investigate several methods and show that a good binarization is key to an improved writer identification in papyri writings. We focus mainly on writer retrieval using unsupervised feature methods based on traditional or self-supervised-based methods. It is, however, also comparable to the state of the art supervised deep learning-based method in the case of writer classification/re-identification.
In this paper a public database for writer retrieval, writer identification and word spotting is presented. The CVL-Database consists of 7 different handwritten texts (1 German and 6 English Texts) and 311 different writers. For each text an RGB color image (300 dpi) comprising the handwritten text and the printed text sample are available as well as a cropped version (only handwritten). A unique ID identifies the writer, whereas the bounding boxes for each single word are stored in an XML file. An evaluation of the best algorithms of the ICDAR and ICHFR writer identification contest has been performed on the CVL-database.
This paper addresses writer identification and writer retrieval which is considered as a challenging problem in the document analysis and recognition field. In this work, a novel pipeline is proposed for the problem at hand by employing a unified neural network architecture consisting of the ResNet-20 as a feature extractor and an integrated NetVLAD layer, inspired by the vector of locally aggregated descriptors (VLAD), in the head of the latter part. Having defined this architecture, the triplet semi-hard loss function is used to directly learn an embedding for individual input image patches. Subsequently, generalized max-pooling technique is employed for the aggregation of embedded descriptors of each handwritten image. Also, a novel re-ranking strategy is introduced for the task of identification and retrieval based on $k$-reciprocal nearest neighbors, and it is shown that the pipeline can benefit tremendously from this step. Experimental evaluation has been done on the three publicly available datasets: the ICDAR 2013, CVL, and KHATT datasets. Results indicate that while we perform comparably to the state-of-the-art on the KHATT, our writer identification and writer retrieval pipeline achieves superior performance on the ICDAR 2013 and CVL datasets in terms of mAP.
Automatic writer identification is a common problem in document analysis. State-of-the-art methods typically focus on the feature extraction step with traditional or deep-learning-based techniques. In retrieval problems, re-ranking is a commonly used technique to improve the results. Re-ranking refines an initial ranking result by using the knowledge contained in the ranked result, e. g., by exploiting nearest neighbor relations. To the best of our knowledge, re-ranking has not been used for writer identification/retrieval. A possible reason might be that publicly available benchmark datasets contain only few samples per writer which makes a re-ranking less promising. We show that a re-ranking step based on k-reciprocal nearest neighbor relationships is advantageous for writer identification, even if only a few samples per writer are available. We use these reciprocal relationships in two ways: encode them into new vectors, as originally proposed, or integrate them in terms of query-expansion. We show that both techniques outperform the baseline results in terms of mAP on three writer identification datasets.
This competition investigates the performance of large-scale retrieval of historical document images based on writing style. Based on large image data sets provided by cultural heritage institutions and digital libraries, providing a total of 20 000 document images representing about 10 000 writers, divided in three types: writers of (i) manuscript books, (ii) letters, (iii) charters and legal documents. We focus on the task of automatic image retrieval to simulate common scenarios of humanities research, such as writer retrieval. The most teams submitted traditional methods not using deep learning techniques. The competition results show that a combination of methods is outperforming single methods. Furthermore, letters are much more difficult to retrieve than manuscripts.
Deep Convolutional Neural Networks (CNN) have shown great success in supervised classification tasks such as character classification or dating. Deep learning methods typically need a lot of annotated training data, which is not available in many scenarios. In these cases, traditional methods are often better than or equivalent to deep learning methods. In this paper, we propose a simple, yet effective, way to learn CNN activation features in an unsupervised manner. Therefore, we train a deep residual network using surrogate classes. The surrogate classes are created by clustering the training dataset, where each cluster index represents one surrogate class. The activations from the penultimate CNN layer serve as features for subsequent classification tasks. We evaluate the feature representations on two publicly available datasets. The focus lies on the ICDAR17 competition dataset on historical document writer identification (Historical-WI). We show that the activation features trained without supervision are superior to descriptors of state-of-the-art writer identification methods. Additionally, we achieve comparable results in the case of handwriting classification using the ICFHR16 competition dataset on historical Latin script types (CLaMM16).
The encoding of local features is an essential part for writer identification and writer retrieval. While CNN activations have already been used as local features in related works, the encoding of these features has attracted little attention so far. In this work, we compare the established VLAD encoding with triangulation embedding. We further investigate generalized max pooling as an alternative to sum pooling and the impact of decorrelation and Exemplar SVMs. With these techniques, we set new standards on two publicly available datasets (ICDAR13, KHATT).