Functional dissociations versus post-hoc selection: Moving beyond the Stockart et al. (2025) compromise
원문 초록
Stockart et al. (2025) recommend guidelines for best practices in the field of unconscious cognition. However, they condone the repeatedly criticized technique of excluding trials with high visibility ratings or of participants with high sensitivity for the critical stimulus. Based on standard signal detection theory for discrimination judgments, we show that post-hoc trial selection only isolates points of neutral response bias but remains consistent with uncomfortably high levels of sensitivity. We argue that post-hoc selection constitutes a sampling fallacy that capitalizes on chance, generates regression artifacts, and wrongly ascribes unconscious processing to stimulus conditions that may be far from indiscriminable. As an alternative, we advocate the study of functional dissociations, where direct (D) and indirect (I) measures are conceptualized as spanning up a two-dimensional D-I-space and where single, sensitivity, and double dissociations appear as distinct curve patterns. While Stockart et al.'s recommendations cover only a single line of that space where D is close to zero, functional dissociations can utilize the entire space, circumventing requirements like null visibility and exhaustive reliability, and allowing for the planful measurement of theoretically meaningful functional relationships between experimentally controlled variables.
함께 살펴볼 논문
공통 태그를 근거로 연결했습니다. 실제 인용 관계나 논문의 우수성을 뜻하지 않습니다.
Generative Latent Kernel Modeling for Blind Motion Deblurring
Differentially Private Relational Learning with Entity-level Privacy Guarantees
EtiCor++: Towards Understanding Etiquettical Bias in LLMs
Fragility in Average Treatment Effect on the Treated under Limited Covariate Support
Assessing parameter identifiability of a hemodynamics PDE model using spectral surrogates and dimension reduction
ACCESS DENIED INC: The First Benchmark Environment for Sensitivity Awareness
토론
이 논문과 연결된 포럼 글이 아직 없습니다.