Non-Determinism and the Lawlessness of Machine Learning Code
원문 초록
Legal literature on machine learning (ML) tends to focus on harms, and thus tends to reason about individual model outcomes and summary error rates. This focus has masked important aspects of ML that are rooted in its reliance on randomness -- namely, stochasticity and non-determinism. While some recent work has begun to reason about the relationship between stochasticity and arbitrariness in legal contexts, the role of non-determinism more broadly remains unexamined. In this paper, we clarify the overlap and differences between these two concepts, and show that the effects of non-determinism, and consequently its implications for the law, become clearer from the perspective of reasoning about ML outputs as distributions over possible outcomes. This distributional viewpoint accounts for randomness by emphasizing the possible outcomes of ML. Importantly, this type of reasoning is not exclusive with current legal reasoning; it complements (and in fact can strengthen) analyses concerning individual, concrete outcomes for specific automated decisions. By illuminating the important role of non-determinism, we demonstrate that ML code falls outside of the cyberlaw frame of treating ``code as law,'' as this frame assumes that code is deterministic. We conclude with a brief discussion of what work ML can do to constrain the potentially harm-inducing effects of non-determinism, and we indicate where the law must do work to bridge the gap between its current individual-outcome focus and the distributional approach that we recommend.
함께 살펴볼 논문
공통 태그를 근거로 연결했습니다. 실제 인용 관계나 논문의 우수성을 뜻하지 않습니다.
Can ChatGPT Perform Reasoning Using the IRAC Method in Analyzing Legal Scenarios Like a Lawyer?
LLM-based HSE Compliance Assessment: Benchmark, Performance, and Advancements
Incorporating Legal Structure in Retrieval-Augmented Generation: A Case Study on Copyright Fair Use
CaseGen: A Benchmark for Multi-Stage Legal Case Documents Generation
JUREX-4E: Juridical Expert-Annotated Four-Element Knowledge Base for Legal Reasoning
NitiBench: A Comprehensive Studies of LLM Frameworks Capabilities for Thai Legal Question Answering
토론
이 논문과 연결된 포럼 글이 아직 없습니다.