Recent advancements in machine learning (ML) are transforming the field of structural biology. For example, AlphaFold, a groundbreaking neural network for protein structure prediction, has been widely adopted by researchers. The availability of easy-to-use interfaces and interpretable outcomes from the neural network architecture, such as the confidence scores used to color the predicted structures, have made AlphaFold accessible even to non-ML experts. In this paper, we present various methods for representing protein 3D structures from low- to high-resolution, and show how interpretable ML methods can support tasks such as predicting protein structures, protein function, and protein-protein interactions. This survey also emphasizes the significance of interpreting and visualizing ML-based inference for structure-based protein representations that enhance interpretability and knowledge discovery. Developing such interpretable approaches promises to further accelerate fields including drug development and protein design.
Application of artificial intelligence (AI) has been ubiquitous in the growth of research in the areas of basic sciences. Frequent use of machine learning (ML) and deep learning (DL) based methodologies by researchers has resulted in significant advancements in the last decade. These techniques led to notable performance enhancements in different tasks such as protein structure prediction, drug-target binding affinity prediction, and molecular property prediction. In material science literature, it is well-known that crystalline materials exhibit topological structures. Such topological structures may be represented as graphs and utilization of graph neural network (GNN) based approaches could help encoding them into an augmented representation space. Primarily, such frameworks adopt supervised learning techniques targeted towards downstream property prediction tasks on the basis of electronic properties (formation energy, bandgap, total energy, etc.) and crystalline structures. Generally, such type of frameworks rely highly on the handcrafted atom feature representations along with the structural representations. In this paper, we propose an unsupervised framework namely, CrysAtom, using untagged crystal data to generate dense vector representation of atoms, which can be utilized in existing GNN-based property predictor models to accurately predict important properties of crystals. Empirical results show that our dense representation embeds chemical properties of atoms and enhance the performance of the baseline property predictor models significantly.
Proteins are the fundamental macromolecules that play diverse and crucial roles in all living matter and have tremendous implications in healthcare, manufacturing, and biotechnology. Their functions are largely determined by the sequences of amino acids that compose them and their unique three-dimensional structures when folded. The recent surge in highly accurate computational protein structure prediction tools has equipped scientists with the means to derive preliminary structural insights without the onerous costs of experimental structure determination. These breakthroughs hold profound promise for building robust and efficient in silico protein design systems. While the prospect of designing de novo proteins with precise computational accuracy remains a grand challenge in biochemical engineering, conventional assembly-based and rational design methods often grapple with the expansive design space, resulting in suboptimal design success rates. Despite recently emerged deep learning-based models have shown promise in improving the efficiency of the computational protein design process, a significant gap persists between current design paradigms and their experimental realization. This thesis will investigate the potential of deep generative models in refining protein structure and sequence design methods, aiming to develop frameworks capable of crafting novel protein sequences with predetermined structures or specific functionalities. By harnessing extensive protein databases and cutting-edge neural architectures, this research aims to enhance precision and robustness in current protein design paradigms, potentially paving the way for advancements across various scientific fields.
The AlphaFold series has transformed protein structure prediction with remarkable accuracy, often matching experimental methods. AlphaFold2, AlphaFold-Multimer, and the latest AlphaFold3 represent significant strides in predicting single protein chains, protein complexes, and biomolecular structures. While AlphaFold2 and AlphaFold-Multimer are open-sourced, facilitating rapid and reliable predictions, AlphaFold3 remains partially accessible through a limited online server and has not been open-sourced, restricting further development. To address these challenges, the PaddleHelix team is developing HelixFold3, aiming to replicate AlphaFold3's capabilities. Leveraging insights from previous models and extensive datasets, HelixFold3 achieves accuracy comparable to AlphaFold3 in predicting the structures of the conventional ligands, nucleic acids, and proteins. The initial release of HelixFold3 is available as open source on GitHub for academic research, promising to advance biomolecular research and accelerate discoveries. The latest version will be continuously updated on the HelixFold3 web server, providing both interactive visualization and API access.
Biomedical data is inherently multimodal, consisting of electronic health records, medical imaging, digital pathology, genome sequencing, wearable sensors, and more. The application of artificial intelligence tools to these multifaceted sensing technologies has the potential to revolutionize the prognosis, diagnosis, and management of human health and disease. However, current approaches to biomedical AI typically only train and evaluate with one or a small set of medical modalities and tasks. This limitation hampers the development of comprehensive tools that can leverage the rich interconnected information across many heterogeneous biomedical sensors. To address this challenge, we present MultiMed, a benchmark designed to evaluate and enable large-scale learning across a wide spectrum of medical modalities and tasks. MultiMed consists of 2.56 million samples across ten medical modalities such as medical reports, pathology, genomics, and protein data, and is structured into eleven challenging tasks, including disease prognosis, protein structure prediction, and medical question answering. Using MultiMed, we conduct comprehensive experiments benchmarking state-of-the-art unimodal, multimodal, and multitask models. Our analysis highlights the advantages of training large-scale medical models across many related modalities and tasks. Moreover, MultiMed enables studies of generalization across related medical concepts, robustness to real-world noisy data and distribution shifts, and novel modality combinations to improve prediction performance. MultiMed will be publicly available and regularly updated and welcomes inputs from the community.
Protein structure prediction is pivotal for understanding the structure-function relationship of proteins, advancing biological research, and facilitating pharmaceutical development and experimental design. While deep learning methods and the expanded availability of experimental 3D protein structures have accelerated structure prediction, the dynamic nature of protein structures has received limited attention. This study introduces an innovative 4D diffusion model incorporating molecular dynamics (MD) simulation data to learn dynamic protein structures. Our approach is distinguished by the following components: (1) a unified diffusion model capable of generating dynamic protein structures, including both the backbone and side chains, utilizing atomic grouping and side-chain dihedral angle predictions; (2) a reference network that enhances structural consistency by integrating the latent embeddings of the initial 3D protein structures; and (3) a motion alignment module aimed at improving temporal structural coherence across multiple time steps. To our knowledge, this is the first diffusion-based model aimed at predicting protein trajectories across multiple time steps simultaneously. Validation on benchmark datasets demonstrates that our model exhibits high accuracy in predicting dynamic 3D structures of proteins containing up to 256 amino acids over 32 time steps, effectively capturing both local flexibility in stable states and significant conformational changes. URL: https://fudan-generative-vision.github.io/AlphaFolding/#/
Determining the 3D structures of proteins is essential in understanding their behavior in the cellular environment. Computational methods of predicting protein structures have advanced, but assessing prediction accuracy remains a challenge. The traditional method, RMSD, relies on experimentally determined structures and lacks insight into improvement areas of predictions. We propose an alternative: analyzing dihedral angles, bypassing the need for the reference structure of an evaluated protein. Our method segments proteins into amino acid subsequences and searches for matches, comparing dihedral angles across numerous proteins to compute a metric using Mahalanobis distance. Evaluated on many predictions, our approach correlates with RMSD and identifies areas for prediction enhancement. This method offers a promising route for accurate protein structure prediction assessment and improvement.
The three-dimensional structure of proteins plays a crucial role in determining their function. Protein structure prediction methods, like AlphaFold, offer rapid access to a protein structure. However, large protein complexes cannot be reliably predicted, and proteins are dynamic, making it important to resolve their full conformational distribution. Single-particle cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) is a powerful tool for determining the structures of large protein complexes. Importantly, the numerous images of a given protein contain underutilized information about conformational heterogeneity. These images are very noisy projections of the protein, and traditional methods for cryo-EM reconstruction are limited to recovering only one or a few consensus conformations. In this paper, we introduce cryoSPHERE, which is a deep learning method that uses a nominal protein structure (e.g., from AlphaFold) as input, learns how to divide it into segments, and moves these segments as approximately rigid bodies to fit the different conformations present in the cryo-EM dataset. This approach provides enough constraints to enable meaningful reconstructions of single protein structural ensembles. We demonstrate this with two synthetic datasets featuring varying levels of noise, as well as two real dataset. We show that cryoSPHERE is very resilient to the high levels of noise typically encountered in experiments, where we see consistent improvements over the current state-of-the-art for heterogeneous reconstruction.
Multiple Sequence Alignment (MSA) plays a pivotal role in unveiling the evolutionary trajectories of protein families. The accuracy of protein structure predictions is often compromised for protein sequences that lack sufficient homologous information to construct high quality MSA. Although various methods have been proposed to generate virtual MSA under these conditions, they fall short in comprehensively capturing the intricate coevolutionary patterns within MSA or require guidance from external oracle models. Here we introduce MSAGPT, a novel approach to prompt protein structure predictions via MSA generative pretraining in the low MSA regime. MSAGPT employs a simple yet effective 2D evolutionary positional encoding scheme to model complex evolutionary patterns. Endowed by this, its flexible 1D MSA decoding framework facilitates zero or few shot learning. Moreover, we demonstrate that leveraging the feedback from AlphaFold2 can further enhance the model capacity via Rejective Fine tuning (RFT) and Reinforcement Learning from AF2 Feedback (RLAF). Extensive experiments confirm the efficacy of MSAGPT in generating faithful virtual MSA to enhance the structure prediction accuracy. The transfer learning capabilities also highlight its great potential for facilitating other protein tasks.
AlphaFold 3 (AF3), the latest version of protein structure prediction software, goes beyond its predecessors by predicting protein-protein complexes. It could revolutionize drug discovery and protein engineering, marking a major step towards comprehensive, automated protein structure prediction. However, independent validation of AF3's predictions is necessary. Evaluated using the SKEMPI 2.0 database which involves 317 protein-protein complexes and 8338 mutations, AF3 complex structures give rise to a very good Pearson correlation coefficient of 0.86 for predicting protein-protein binding free energy changes upon mutation, slightly less than the 0.88 achieved earlier with the Protein Data Bank (PDB) structures. Nonetheless, AF3 complex structures led to a 8.6% increase in the prediction RMSE compared to original PDB complex structures. Additionally, some of AF3's complex structures have large errors, which were not captured in its ipTM performance metric. Finally, it is found that AF3's complex structures are not reliable for intrinsically flexible regions or domains.
Motivation: Protein embedding, which represents proteins as numerical vectors, is a crucial step in various learning-based protein annotation/classification problems, including gene ontology prediction, protein-protein interaction prediction, and protein structure prediction. However, existing protein embedding methods are often computationally expensive due to their large number of parameters, which can reach millions or even billions. The growing availability of large-scale protein datasets and the need for efficient analysis tools have created a pressing demand for efficient protein embedding methods. Results: We propose a novel protein embedding approach based on multi-teacher distillation learning, which leverages the knowledge of multiple pre-trained protein embedding models to learn a compact and informative representation of proteins. Our method achieves comparable performance to state-of-the-art methods while significantly reducing computational costs and resource requirements. Specifically, our approach reduces computational time by ~70\% and maintains almost the same accuracy as the original large models. This makes our method well-suited for large-scale protein analysis and enables the bioinformatics community to perform protein embedding tasks more efficiently.
AlphaFold can be used for both single-chain and multi-chain protein structure prediction, while the latter becomes extremely challenging as the number of chains increases. In this work, by taking each chain as a node and assembly actions as edges, we show that an acyclic undirected connected graph can be used to predict the structure of multi-chain protein complexes (a.k.a., protein complex modelling, PCM). However, there are still two challenges: 1) The huge combinatorial optimization space of $N^{N-2}$ ($N$ is the number of chains) for the PCM problem can easily lead to high computational cost. 2) The scales of protein complexes exhibit distribution shift due to variance in chain numbers, which calls for the generalization in modelling complexes of various scales. To address these challenges, we propose GAPN, a Generative Adversarial Policy Network powered by domain-specific rewards and adversarial loss through policy gradient for automatic PCM prediction. Specifically, GAPN learns to efficiently search through the immense assembly space and optimize the direct docking reward through policy gradient. Importantly, we design an adversarial reward function to enhance the receptive field of our model. In this way, GAPN will simultaneously focus on a specific batch of complexes and the global assembly rules learned from complexes with varied chain numbers. Empirically, we have achieved both significant accuracy (measured by RMSD and TM-Score) and efficiency improvements compared to leading PCM softwares.
While monomer protein structure prediction tools boast impressive accuracy, the prediction of protein complex structures remains a daunting challenge in the field. This challenge is particularly pronounced in scenarios involving complexes with protein chains from different species, such as antigen-antibody interactions, where accuracy often falls short. Limited by the accuracy of complex prediction, tasks based on precise protein-protein interaction analysis also face obstacles. In this report, we highlight the ongoing advancements of our protein complex structure prediction model, HelixFold-Multimer, underscoring its enhanced performance. HelixFold-Multimer provides precise predictions for diverse protein complex structures, especially in therapeutic protein interactions. Notably, HelixFold-Multimer achieves remarkable success in antigen-antibody and peptide-protein structure prediction, greatly surpassing AlphaFold 3. HelixFold-Multimer is now available for public use on the PaddleHelix platform, offering both a general version and an antigen-antibody version. Researchers can conveniently access and utilize this service for their development needs.
Computational prediction of stable crystal structures has a profound impact on the large-scale discovery of novel functional materials. However, predicting the crystal structure solely from a material's composition or formula is a promising yet challenging task, as traditional ab initio crystal structure prediction (CSP) methods rely on time-consuming global searches and first-principles free energy calculations. Inspired by the recent success of deep learning approaches in protein structure prediction, which utilize pairwise amino acid interactions to describe 3D structures, we present AlphaCrystal-II, a novel knowledge-based solution that exploits the abundant inter-atomic interaction patterns found in existing known crystal structures. AlphaCrystal-II predicts the atomic distance matrix of a target crystal material and employs this matrix to reconstruct its 3D crystal structure. By leveraging the wealth of inter-atomic relationships of known crystal structures, our approach demonstrates remarkable effectiveness and reliability in structure prediction through comprehensive experiments. This work highlights the potential of data-driven methods in accelerating the discovery and design of new materials with tailored properties.
The effect of mutations on protein structures is usually rather localized and minor. Finding a mutation that can single-handedly change the fold and/or topology of a protein structure is a rare exception. The A31P mutant of the homodimeric Repressor of Primer (Rop) protein is one such exception: This single mutation -and as demonstrated by two independent crystal structure determinations- can convert the canonical (left-handed/all-antiparallel) 4-alpha-helical bundle of Rop, to a new form (right-handed/mixed parallel and antiparallel bundle) displaying a previously unobserved 'bisecting U' topology. The main problem with understanding the dramatic effect of this mutation on the folding of Rop is to understand its very existence : Most computational methods appear to agree that the mutation should have had no appreciable effect, with the majority of energy minimization methods and protein structure prediction protocols indicating that this mutation is fully consistent with the native Rop structure, requiring only a local and minor change at the mutation site. Here we use two long (10 us each) molecular dynamics simulations to compare the stability and dynamics of the native Rop versus a hypothetical structure that is identical with the native Rop but is carrying this single Alanine-31 to Proline mutation. Comparative analysis of the two trajectories convincingly shows that in contrast to the indications from energy minimization -but in agreement with the experimental data-, this hypothetical native-like A31P structure is unstable, with its turn regions almost completely unfolding, even under the relatively mild 320K NpT simulations that we have used for this study. We discuss the implication of these findings for the folding of the A31P mutant, especially with respect to the proposed model of a double-funneled energy landscape.
AlphaFold2 (AF2) has emerged in recent years as a groundbreaking innovation that has revolutionized several scientific fields, in particular structural biology, drug design and the elucidation of disease mechanisms. Many scientists now use AF2 on a daily basis, including non-specialist users. This chapter is aimed at the latter. Tips and tricks for getting the most out of AF2 to produce a high quality biological model are discussed here. We suggest to non-specialist users how to maintain a critical perspective when working with AF2 models and provide guidelines on how to properly evaluate them. After showing how to perform our own structure prediction using ColabFold, we list several ways to improve AF2 models by adding information that is missing from the original AF2 model. By using software such as AlphaFill to add cofactors and ligands to the models, or MODELLER to add disulfide bridges between cysteines, we guide users to build a high quality biological model suitable for applications such as drug design, protein interaction or molecular dynamics studies.
Protein representation learning plays a crucial role in understanding the structure and function of proteins, which are essential biomolecules involved in various biological processes. In recent years, deep learning has emerged as a powerful tool for protein modeling due to its ability to learn complex patterns and representations from large-scale protein data. This comprehensive survey aims to provide an overview of the recent advances in deep learning techniques applied to protein science. The survey begins by introducing the developments of deep learning based protein models and emphasizes the importance of protein representation learning in drug discovery, protein engineering, and function annotation. It then delves into the fundamentals of deep learning, including convolutional neural networks, recurrent neural networks, attention models, and graph neural networks in modeling protein sequences, structures, and functions, and explores how these techniques can be used to extract meaningful features and capture intricate relationships within protein data. Next, the survey presents various applications of deep learning in the field of proteins, including protein structure prediction, protein-protein interaction prediction, protein function prediction, etc. Furthermore, it highlights the challenges and limitations of these deep learning techniques and also discusses potential solutions and future directions for overcoming these challenges. This comprehensive survey provides a valuable resource for researchers and practitioners in the field of proteins who are interested in harnessing the power of deep learning techniques. By consolidating the latest advancements and discussing potential avenues for improvement, this review contributes to the ongoing progress in protein research and paves the way for future breakthroughs in the field.
Deep learning has made significant progress in protein structure prediction, advancing the development of computational biology. However, despite the high accuracy achieved in predicting single-chain structures, a significant number of large homo-oligomeric assemblies exhibit internal symmetry, posing a major challenge in structure determination. The performances of existing deep learning methods are limited since the symmetrical protein assembly usually has a long sequence, making structural computation infeasible. In addition, multiple identical subunits in symmetrical protein complex cause the issue of supervision ambiguity in label assignment, requiring a consistent structure modeling for the training. To tackle these problems, we propose a protein folding framework called SGNet to model protein-protein interactions in symmetrical assemblies. SGNet conducts feature extraction on a single subunit and generates the whole assembly using our proposed symmetry module, which largely mitigates computational problems caused by sequence length. Thanks to the elaborate design of modeling symmetry consistently, we can model all global symmetry types in quaternary protein structure prediction. Extensive experimental results on a benchmark of symmetrical protein complexes further demonstrate the effectiveness of our method.
Modern life sciences research is increasingly relying on artificial intelligence approaches to model biological systems, primarily centered around the use of machine learning (ML) models. Although ML is undeniably useful for identifying patterns in large, complex data sets, its widespread application in biological sciences represents a significant deviation from traditional methods of scientific inquiry. As such, the interplay between these models and scientific understanding in biology is a topic with important implications for the future of scientific research, yet it is a subject that has received little attention. Here, we draw from an epistemological toolkit to contextualize recent applications of ML in biological sciences under modern philosophical theories of understanding, identifying general principles that can guide the design and application of ML systems to model biological phenomena and advance scientific knowledge. We propose that conceptions of scientific understanding as information compression, qualitative intelligibility, and dependency relation modelling provide a useful framework for interpreting ML-mediated understanding of biological systems. Through a detailed analysis of two key application areas of ML in modern biological research - protein structure prediction and single cell RNA-sequencing - we explore how these features have thus far enabled ML systems to advance scientific understanding of their target phenomena, how they may guide the development of future ML models, and the key obstacles that remain in preventing ML from achieving its potential as a tool for biological discovery. Consideration of the epistemological features of ML applications in biology will improve the prospects of these methods to solve important problems and advance scientific understanding of living systems.
Proteins are essential for life, and their structure determines their function. The protein secondary structure is formed by the folding of the protein primary structure, and the protein tertiary structure is formed by the bending and folding of the secondary structure. Therefore, the study of protein secondary structure is very helpful to the overall understanding of protein structure. Although the accuracy of protein secondary structure prediction has continuously improved with the development of machine learning and deep learning, progress in the field of protein structure prediction, unfortunately, remains insufficient to meet the large demand for protein information. Therefore, based on the advantages of deep learning-based methods in feature extraction and learning ability, this paper adopts a two-dimensional fusion deep neural network model, DstruCCN, which uses Convolutional Neural Networks (CCN) and a supervised Transformer protein language model for single-sequence protein structure prediction. The training features of the two are combined to predict the protein Transformer binding site matrix, and then the three-dimensional structure is reconstructed using energy minimization.