Researchers have reported high decoding accuracy (>95%) using non-invasive Electroencephalogram (EEG) signals for brain-computer interface (BCI) decoding tasks like image decoding, emotion recognition, auditory spatial attention detection, etc. Since these EEG data were usually collected with well-designed paradigms in labs, the reliability and robustness of the corresponding decoding methods were doubted by some researchers, and they argued that such decoding accuracy was overestimated due to the inherent temporal autocorrelation of EEG signals. However, the coupling between the stimulus-driven neural responses and the EEG temporal autocorrelations makes it difficult to confirm whether this overestimation exists in truth. Furthermore, the underlying pitfalls behind overestimated decoding accuracy have not been fully explained due to a lack of appropriate formulation. In this work, we formulate the pitfall in various EEG decoding tasks in a unified framework. EEG data were recorded from watermelons to remove stimulus-driven neural responses. Labels were assigned to continuous EEG according to the experimental design for EEG recording of several typical datasets, and then the decoding methods were conducted. The results showed the label can be successfully decoded as long as continuous EEG data with the same label were split into training and test sets. Further analysis indicated that high accuracy of various BCI decoding tasks could be achieved by associating labels with EEG intrinsic temporal autocorrelation features. These results underscore the importance of choosing the right experimental designs and data splits in BCI decoding tasks to prevent inflated accuracies due to EEG temporal autocorrelation.
Automated classification of electroencephalogram (EEG) signals is complex due to their high dimensionality, non-stationarity, low signal-to-noise ratio, and variability between subjects. Deep neural networks (DNNs) have shown promising results for EEG classification, but the above challenges hinder their performance. Euclidean Alignment (EA) and Data Augmentation (DA) are two promising techniques for improving DNN training by permitting the use of data from multiple subjects, increasing the data, and regularizing the available data. In this paper, we perform a detailed evaluation of the combined use of EA and DA with DNNs for EEG decoding. We trained individual models and shared models with data from multiple subjects and showed that combining EA and DA generates synergies that improve the accuracy of most models and datasets. Also, the shared models combined with fine-tuning benefited the most, with an overall increase of 8.41\% in classification accuracy.
Machine learning has enhanced the performance of decoding signals indicating human behaviour. EEG decoding, as an exemplar indicating neural activity and human thoughts non-invasively, has been helpful in neural activity analysis and aiding patients via brain-computer interfaces. However, training machine learning algorithms on EEG encounters two primary challenges: variability across data sets and privacy concerns using data from individuals and data centres. Our objective is to address these challenges by integrating transfer learning for data variability and federated learning for data privacy into a unified approach. We introduce the Sandwich as a novel deep privacy-preserving meta-framework combining transfer learning and federated learning. The Sandwich framework comprises three components: federated networks (first layers) that handle data set differences at the input level, a shared network (middle layer) learning common rules and applying transfer learning, and individual classifiers (final layers) for specific tasks of each data set. It enables the central network (central server) to benefit from multiple data sets, while local branches (local servers) maintain data and label privacy. We evaluated the `Sandwich' meta-architecture in various configurations using the BEETL motor imagery challenge, a benchmark for heterogeneous EEG data sets. Compared with baseline models, our `Sandwich' implementations showed superior performance. The best-performing model, the Inception Sandwich with deep set alignment (Inception-SD-Deepset), exceeded baseline methods by 9%. The `Sandwich' framework demonstrates significant advancements in federated deep transfer learning for diverse tasks and data sets. It outperforms conventional deep learning methods, showcasing the potential for effective use of larger, heterogeneous data sets with enhanced privacy as a model-agnostic meta-framework.
Decoding EEG signals is crucial for unraveling human brain and advancing brain-computer interfaces. Traditional machine learning algorithms have been hindered by the high noise levels and inherent inter-person variations in EEG signals. Recent advances in deep neural networks (DNNs) have shown promise, owing to their advanced nonlinear modeling capabilities. However, DNN still faces challenge in decoding EEG samples of unseen individuals. To address this, this paper introduces a novel approach by incorporating the conditional identification information of each individual into the neural network, thereby enhancing model representation through the synergistic interaction of EEG and personal traits. We test our model on the WithMe dataset and demonstrated that the inclusion of these identifiers substantially boosts accuracy for both subjects in the training set and unseen subjects. This enhancement suggests promising potential for improving for EEG interpretability and understanding of relevant identification features.
Objective: The integration of Deep Learning (DL) algorithms on brain signal analysis is still in its nascent stages compared to their success in fields like Computer Vision. This is particularly true for BCI, where the brain activity is decoded to control external devices without requiring muscle control. Electroencephalography (EEG) is a widely adopted choice for designing BCI systems due to its non-invasive and cost-effective nature and excellent temporal resolution. Still, it comes at the expense of limited training data, poor signal-to-noise, and a large variability across and within-subject recordings. Finally, setting up a BCI system with many electrodes takes a long time, hindering the widespread adoption of reliable DL architectures in BCIs outside research laboratories. To improve adoption, we need to improve user comfort using, for instance, reliable algorithms that operate with few electrodes. Approach: Our research aims to develop a DL algorithm that delivers effective results with a limited number of electrodes. Taking advantage of the Augmented Covariance Method and the framework of SPDNet, we propose the Phase-SPDNet architecture and analyze its performance and the interpretability of the results. The evaluation is conducted on 5-fold cross-validation, using only three electrodes positioned above the Motor Cortex. The methodology was tested on nearly 100 subjects from several open-source datasets using the Mother Of All BCI Benchmark (MOABB) framework. Main results: The results of our Phase-SPDNet demonstrate that the augmented approach combined with the SPDNet significantly outperforms all the current state-of-the-art DL architecture in MI decoding. Significance: This new architecture is explainable and with a low number of trainable parameters.
Brain-computer interface (BCI) technology facilitates communication between the human brain and computers, primarily utilizing electroencephalography (EEG) signals to discern human intentions. Although EEG-based BCI systems have been developed for paralysis individuals, ongoing studies explore systems for speech imagery and motor imagery (MI). This study introduces FingerNet, a specialized network for fine MI classification, departing from conventional gross MI studies. The proposed FingerNet could extract spatial and temporal features from EEG signals, improving classification accuracy within the same hand. The experimental results demonstrated that performance showed significantly higher accuracy in classifying five finger-tapping tasks, encompassing thumb, index, middle, ring, and little finger movements. FingerNet demonstrated dominant performance compared to the conventional baseline models, EEGNet and DeepConvNet. The average accuracy for FingerNet was 0.3049, whereas EEGNet and DeepConvNet exhibited lower accuracies of 0.2196 and 0.2533, respectively. Statistical validation also demonstrates the predominance of FingerNet over baseline networks. For biased predictions, particularly for thumb and index classes, we led to the implementation of weighted cross-entropy and also adapted the weighted cross-entropy, a method conventionally employed to mitigate class imbalance. The proposed FingerNet involves optimizing network structure, improving performance, and exploring applications beyond fine MI. Moreover, the weighted Cross Entropy approach employed to address such biased predictions appears to have broader applicability and relevance across various domains involving multi-class classification tasks. We believe that effective execution of motor imagery can be achieved not only for fine MI, but also for local muscle MI
The imbalanced development between deep learning-based model design and motor imagery (MI) data acquisition raises concerns about the potential overfitting issue—models can identify training data well but fail to generalize test data. In this study, a Spatial Variation Generation (SVG) algorithm for MI data augmentation is proposed to alleviate the overfitting issue. In essence, SVG generates MI data using variations of electrode placement and brain spatial pattern, ultimately elevating the density of the raw sample vicinity. The proposed SVG prevents models from memorizing the training data by replacing the raw samples with the proper vicinal distribution. Moreover, SVG generates a uniform distribution and stabilizes the training process of models. In comparison studies involving five deep learning-based models across eight datasets, the proposed SVG algorithm exhibited a notable improvement of 0.021 in the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC). The improvement achieved by SVG outperforms other data augmentation algorithms. Further results from the ablation study verify the effectiveness of each component of SVG. Finally, the studies in the control group with varying numbers of samples show that the SVG algorithm consistently improves the AUC, with improvements ranging from approximately 0.02 to 0.15.
The 2024 ICASSP Auditory EEG Signal Processing Grand Challenge concerns the decoding of electroencephalography (EEG) measurements taken from participants who listened to speech material. This work details our solution to the match-mismatch sub-task: given a short temporal segment of EEG recordings and several candidate speech segments, the task is to classify which of the speech segments was time-aligned with the EEG signals. We show that high-frequency gamma-band responses to the speech envelope can be detected with a high accuracy. By jointly assessing gamma-band responses and low-frequency envelope tracking, we develop a match-mismatch decoder which placed first in this task.
Electroencephalography (EEG) signals are frequently used for various Brain-Computer Interface (BCI) tasks. While Deep Learning (DL) techniques have shown promising results, they are hindered by the substantial data requirements. By leveraging data from multiple subjects, transfer learning enables more effective training of DL models. A technique that is gaining popularity is Euclidean Alignment (EA) due to its ease of use, low computational complexity, and compatibility with Deep Learning models. However, few studies evaluate its impact on the training performance of shared and individual DL models. In this work, we systematically evaluate the effect of EA combined with DL for decoding BCI signals. We used EA to train shared models with data from multiple subjects and evaluated its transferability to new subjects. Our experimental results show that it improves decoding in the target subject by 4.33% and decreases convergence time by more than 70%. We also trained individual models for each subject to use as a majority-voting ensemble classifier. In this scenario, using EA improved the 3-model ensemble accuracy by 3.7%. However, when compared to the shared model with EA, the ensemble accuracy was 3.62% lower.
The variability in EEG signals between different individuals poses a significant challenge when implementing brain-computer interfaces (BCI). Commonly proposed solutions to this problem include deep learning models, due to their increased capacity and generalization, as well as explicit domain adaptation techniques. Here, we introduce the Latent Alignment method that won the Benchmarks for EEG Transfer Learning (BEETL) competition and present its formulation as a deep set applied on the set of trials from a given subject. Its performance is compared to recent statistical domain adaptation techniques under various conditions. The experimental paradigms include motor imagery (MI), oddball event-related potentials (ERP) and sleep stage classification, where different well-established deep learning models are applied on each task. Our experimental results show that performing statistical distribution alignment at later stages in a deep learning model is beneficial to the classification accuracy, yielding the highest performance for our proposed method. We further investigate practical considerations that arise in the context of using deep learning and statistical alignment for EEG decoding. In this regard, we study class-discriminative artifacts that can spuriously improve results for deep learning models, as well as the impact of class-imbalance on alignment. We delineate a trade-off relationship between increased classification accuracy when alignment is performed at later modeling stages, and susceptibility to class-imbalance in the set of trials that the statistics are computed on.
This study delves into the intricacies of emotional contagion and its impact on performance within dyadic interactions. Specifically, it focuses on the context of stereotype-based stress (SBS) during collaborative problem-solving tasks among female pairs. Through an exploration of emotional contagion, this study seeks to unveil its underlying mechanisms and effects. Leveraging EEG-based hyperscanning technology, we introduced an innovative approach known as the functional Graph Contrastive Learning (fGCL), which extracts subject-invariant representations of neural activity patterns from feedback trials. These representations are further subjected to analysis using the Dynamic Graph Classification (DGC) model, aimed at dissecting the process of emotional contagion along three independent temporal stages. The results underscore the substantial role of emotional contagion in shaping the trajectories of participants' performance during collaborative tasks in the presence of SBS conditions. Overall, our research contributes invaluable insights into the neural underpinnings of emotional contagion, thereby enriching our comprehension of the complexities underlying social interactions and emotional dynamics.
Insufficient data is a long-standing challenge for Brain-Computer Interface (BCI) to build a high-performance deep learning model. Though numerous research groups and institutes collect a multitude of EEG datasets for the same BCI task, sharing EEG data from multiple sites is still challenging due to the heterogeneity of devices. The significance of this challenge cannot be overstated, given the critical role of data diversity in fostering model robustness. However, existing works rarely discuss this issue, predominantly centering their attention on model training within a single dataset, often in the context of inter-subject or inter-session settings. In this work, we propose a hierarchical personalized Federated Learning EEG decoding (FLEEG) framework to surmount this challenge. This innovative framework heralds a new learning paradigm for BCI, enabling datasets with disparate data formats to collaborate in the model training process. Each client is assigned a specific dataset and trains a hierarchical personalized model to manage diverse data formats and facilitate information exchange. Meanwhile, the server coordinates the training procedure to harness knowledge gleaned from all datasets, thus elevating overall performance. The framework has been evaluated in Motor Imagery (MI) classification with nine EEG datasets collected by different devices but implementing the same MI task. Results demonstrate that the proposed frame can boost classification performance up to 16.7% by enabling knowledge sharing between multiple datasets, especially for smaller datasets. Visualization results also indicate that the proposed framework can empower the local models to put a stable focus on task-related areas, yielding better performance. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first end-to-end solution to address this important challenge.
Pre-trained large transformer models have achieved remarkable performance in the fields of natural language processing and computer vision. However, the limited availability of public electroencephalogram (EEG) data presents a unique challenge for extending the success of these models to EEG-based tasks. To address this gap, we propose AdaCT, plug-and-play Adapters designed for Converting Time series data into spatio-temporal 2D pseudo-images or text forms. Essentially, AdaCT-I transforms multi-channel or lengthy single-channel time series data into spatio-temporal 2D pseudo-images for fine-tuning pre-trained vision transformers, while AdaCT-T converts short single-channel data into text for fine-tuning pre-trained language transformers. The proposed approach allows for seamless integration of pre-trained vision models and language models in time series decoding tasks, particularly in EEG data analysis. Experimental results on diverse benchmark datasets, including Epileptic Seizure Recognition, Sleep-EDF, and UCI HAR, demonstrate the superiority of AdaCT over baseline methods. Overall, we provide a promising transfer learning framework for leveraging the capabilities of pre-trained vision and language models in EEG-based tasks, thereby advancing the field of time series decoding and enhancing interpretability in EEG data analysis. Our code will be available at https://github.com/wangbxj1234/AdaCE.
Recently, deep learning has shown to be effective for Electroencephalography (EEG) decoding tasks. Yet, its performance can be negatively influenced by two key factors: 1) the high variance and different types of corruption that are inherent in the signal, 2) the EEG datasets are usually relatively small given the acquisition cost, annotation cost and amount of effort needed. Data augmentation approaches for alleviation of this problem have been empirically studied, with augmentation operations on spatial domain, time domain or frequency domain handcrafted based on expertise of domain knowledge. In this work, we propose a principled approach to perform dynamic evolution on the data for improvement of decoding robustness. The approach is based on distributionally robust optimization and achieves robustness by optimizing on a family of evolved data distributions instead of the single training data distribution. We derived a general data evolution framework based on Wasserstein gradient flow (WGF) and provides two different forms of evolution within the framework. Intuitively, the evolution process helps the EEG decoder to learn more robust and diverse features. It is worth mentioning that the proposed approach can be readily integrated with other data augmentation approaches for further improvements. We performed extensive experiments on the proposed approach and tested its performance on different types of corrupted EEG signals. The model significantly outperforms competitive baselines on challenging decoding scenarios.
Electroencephalography (EEG) decoding is a challenging task due to the limited availability of labelled data. While transfer learning is a promising technique to address this challenge, it assumes that transferable data domains and task are known, which is not the case in this setting. This study investigates the transferability of deep learning representations between different EEG decoding tasks. We conduct extensive experiments using state-of-the-art decoding models on two recently released EEG datasets, ERP CORE and M$^3$CV, containing over 140 subjects and 11 distinct cognitive tasks. We measure the transferability of learned representations by pre-training deep neural networks on one task and assessing their ability to decode subsequent tasks. Our experiments demonstrate that, even with linear probing transfer, significant improvements in decoding performance can be obtained, with gains of up to 28% compare with the pure supervised approach. Additionally, we discover evidence that certain decoding paradigms elicit specific and narrow brain activities, while others benefit from pre-training on a broad range of representations. By revealing which tasks transfer well and demonstrating the benefits of transfer learning for EEG decoding, our findings have practical implications for mitigating data scarcity in this setting. The transfer maps generated also provide insights into the hierarchical relations between cognitive tasks, hence enhancing our understanding of how these tasks are connected from a neuroscientific standpoint.
Brain-Machine Interfacing (BMI) has greatly benefited from adopting machine learning methods for feature learning that require extensive data for training, which are often unavailable from a single dataset. Yet, it is difficult to combine data across labs or even data within the same lab collected over the years due to the variation in recording equipment and electrode layouts resulting in shifts in data distribution, changes in data dimensionality, and altered identity of data dimensions. Our objective is to overcome this limitation and learn from many different and diverse datasets across labs with different experimental protocols. To tackle the domain adaptation problem, we developed a novel machine learning framework combining graph neural networks (GNNs) and transfer learning methodologies for non-invasive Motor Imagery (MI) EEG decoding, as an example of BMI. Empirically, we focus on the challenges of learning from EEG data with different electrode layouts and varying numbers of electrodes. We utilise three MI EEG databases collected using very different numbers of EEG sensors (from 22 channels to 64) and layouts (from custom layouts to 10-20). Our model achieved the highest accuracy with lower standard deviations on the testing datasets. This indicates that the GNN-based transfer learning framework can effectively aggregate knowledge from multiple datasets with different electrode layouts, leading to improved generalization in subject-independent MI EEG classification. The findings of this study have important implications for Brain-Computer-Interface (BCI) research, as they highlight a promising method for overcoming the limitations posed by non-unified experimental setups. By enabling the integration of diverse datasets with varying electrode layouts, our proposed approach can help advance the development and application of BMI technologies.
In the realm of EEG decoding, enhancing the performance of artificial neural networks (ANNs) carries significant potential. This study introduces a novel approach, termed "weight freezing", that is anchored on the principles of ANN regularization and neuroscience prior knowledge. The concept of weight freezing revolves around the idea of reducing certain neurons' influence on the decision-making process for a specific EEG task by freezing specific weights in the fully connected layer during the backpropagation process. This is actualized through the use of a mask matrix and a threshold to determine the proportion of weights to be frozen during backpropagation. Moreover, by setting the masked weights to zero, weight freezing can not only realize sparse connections in networks with a fully connected layer as the classifier but also function as an efficacious regularization method for fully connected layers. Through experiments involving three distinct ANN architectures and three widely recognized EEG datasets, we validate the potency of weight freezing. Our method significantly surpasses previous peak performances in classification accuracy across all examined datasets. Supplementary control experiments offer insights into performance differences pre and post weight freezing implementation and scrutinize the influence of the threshold in the weight freezing process. Our study underscores the superior efficacy of weight freezing compared to traditional fully connected networks for EEG feature classification tasks. With its proven effectiveness, this innovative approach holds substantial promise for contributing to future strides in EEG decoding research.
Low-channel EEG devices are crucial for portable and entertainment applications. However, the low spatial resolution of EEG presents challenges in decoding low-channel motor imagery. This study introduces TSFF-Net, a novel network architecture that integrates time-space-frequency features, effectively compensating for the limitations of single-mode feature extraction networks based on time-series or time-frequency modalities. TSFF-Net comprises four main components: time-frequency representation, time-frequency feature extraction, time-space feature extraction, and feature fusion and classification. Time-frequency representation and feature extraction transform raw EEG signals into time-frequency spectrograms and extract relevant features. The time-space network processes time-series EEG trials as input and extracts temporal-spatial features. Feature fusion employs MMD loss to constrain the distribution of time-frequency and time-space features in the Reproducing Kernel Hilbert Space, subsequently combining these features using a weighted fusion approach to obtain effective time-space-frequency features. Moreover, few studies have explored the decoding of three-channel motor imagery based on time-frequency spectrograms. This study proposes a shallow, lightweight decoding architecture (TSFF-img) based on time-frequency spectrograms and compares its classification performance in low-channel motor imagery with other methods using two publicly available datasets. Experimental results demonstrate that TSFF-Net not only compensates for the shortcomings of single-mode feature extraction networks in EEG decoding, but also outperforms other state-of-the-art methods. Overall, TSFF-Net offers considerable advantages in decoding low-channel motor imagery and provides valuable insights for algorithmically enhancing low-channel EEG decoding.
During speech perception, a listener's electroencephalogram (EEG) reflects acoustic-level processing as well as higher-level cognitive factors such as speech comprehension and attention. However, decoding speech from EEG recordings is challenging due to the low signal-to-noise ratios of EEG signals. We report on an approach developed for the ICASSP 2023 'Auditory EEG Decoding' Signal Processing Grand Challenge. A simple ensembling method is shown to considerably improve upon the baseline decoder performance. Even higher classification rates are achieved by jointly decoding the speech-evoked frequency-following response and responses to the temporal envelope of speech, as well as by fine-tuning the decoders to individual subjects. Our results could have applications in the diagnosis of hearing disorders or in cognitively steered hearing aids.
Neurophysiological time-series recordings of brain activity like the electroencephalogram (EEG) or local field potentials can be decoded by machine learning models in order to either control an application, e.g., for communication or rehabilitation after stroke, or to passively monitor the ongoing brain state of the subject, e.g., in a demanding work environment. A typical decoding challenge faced by a brain-computer interface (BCI) is the small dataset size compared to other domains of machine learning like computer vision or natural language processing. The possibilities to tackle classification or regression problems in BCI are to either train a regular model on the available small training data sets or through transfer learning, which utilizes data from other sessions, subjects, or even datasets to train a model. Transfer learning is non-trivial because of the non-stationary of EEG signals between subjects but also within subjects. This variability calls for explicit calibration phases at the start of every session, before BCI applications can be used online. In this study, we present arguments to BCI researchers to encourage the use of embeddings for EEG decoding. In particular, we introduce a simple domain adaptation technique involving both deep learning (when learning the embeddings from the source data) and classical machine learning (for fast calibration on the target data). This technique allows us to learn embeddings across subjects, which deliver a generalized data representation. These can then be fed into subject-specific classifiers in order to minimize their need for calibration data. We conducted offline experiments on the 14 subjects of the High Gamma EEG-BCI Dataset [1]. Embedding functions were obtained by training EEGNet [2] using a leave-one-subject-out (LOSO) protocol, and the embedding vectors were classified by the logistic regression algorithm. Our pipeline was compared to two baseline approaches: EEGNet without subject-specific calibration and the standard FBCSP pipeline in a within-subject training. We observed that the representations learned by the embedding functions were indeed non-stationary across subjects, justifying the need for an additional subject-specific calibration. We also observed that the subject-specific calibration indeed improved the score. Finally, our data suggest, that building upon embeddings requires fewer individual calibration data than the FBCSP baseline to reach satisfactory scores.