The electroencephalography (EEG) signal is a non-stationary, stochastic, and highly non-linear bioelectric signal for which achieving high classification accuracy is challenging, especially when the number of subjects is limited. As frequently used solution, classifiers based on multilayer neural networks has to be implemented without large training data sets and careful tuning. This paper proposes a manifold learning framework to classify two types of EEG data from motor imagery (MI) tasks by discovering lower dimensional geometric structures. For feature extraction, it is implemented by Common Spatial Pattern (CSP) from the preprocessed EEG signals. In the neighborhoods of the features for classification, the local approximation to the support of the data is obtained, and then the features are assigned to the classes with the closest support. A spherical approximation (SPA) classifier is created using spherelets for local approximation, and the extracted features are classified with this manifold-based method. The SPA classifier achieves high accuracy in the 2008 BCI competition data, and the analysis shows that this method can significantly improve the decoding accuracy of MI tasks and exhibit strong robustness for small sample datasets. It would be simple and efficient to tune the two-parameters classifier for the online brain-computer interface(BCI)system.
The Brain-Computer Interface system is a profoundly developing area of experimentation for Motor activities which plays vital role in decoding cognitive activities. Classification of Cognitive-Motor Imagery activities from EEG signals is a critical task. Hence proposed a unique algorithm for classifying left/right-hand movements by utilizing Multi-layer Perceptron Neural Network. Handcrafted statistical Time domain and Power spectral density frequency domain features were extracted and obtained a combined accuracy of 96.02%. Results were compared with the deep learning framework. In addition to accuracy, Precision, F1-Score, and recall was considered as the performance metrics. The intervention of unwanted signals contaminates the EEG signals which influence the performance of the algorithm. Therefore, a novel approach was approached to remove the artifacts using Independent Components Analysis which boosted the performance. Following the selection of appropriate feature vectors that provided acceptable accuracy. The same method was used on all nine subjects. As a result, intra-subject accuracy was obtained for 9 subjects 94.72%. The results show that the proposed approach would be useful to classify the upper limb movements accurately.
Brain-computer interface (BCI) is one of the tools which enables the communication between humans and devices by reflecting intention and status of humans. With the development of artificial intelligence, the interest in communication between humans and drones using electroencephalogram (EEG) is increased. Especially, in the case of controlling drone swarms such as direction or formation, there are many advantages compared with controlling a drone unit. Imagined speech is one of the endogenous BCI paradigms, which can identify intentions of users. When conducting imagined speech, the users imagine the pronunciation as if actually speaking. In contrast, overt speech is a task in which the users directly pronounce the words. When controlling drone swarms using imagined speech, complex commands can be delivered more intuitively, but decoding performance is lower than that of other endogenous BCI paradigms. We proposed the Deep-autoleaner (DAL) to learn EEG features of overt speech for imagined speech-based EEG signals classification. To the best of our knowledge, this study is the first attempt to use EEG features of overt speech to decode imagined speech-based EEG signals with an autoencoder. A total of eight subjects participated in the experiment. When classifying four words, the average accuracy of the DAL was 48.41%. In addition, when comparing the performance between w/o and w/ EEG features of overt speech, there was a performance improvement of 7.42% when including EEG features of overt speech. Hence, we demonstrated that EEG features of overt speech could improve the decoding performance of imagined speech.
Different categories of visual stimuli activate different responses in the human brain. These signals can be captured with EEG for utilization in applications such as Brain-Computer Interface (BCI). However, accurate classification of single-trial data is challenging due to low signal-to-noise ratio of EEG. This work introduces an EEG-ConvTranformer network that is based on multi-headed self-attention. Unlike other transformers, the model incorporates self-attention to capture inter-region interactions. It further extends to adjunct convolutional filters with multi-head attention as a single module to learn temporal patterns. Experimental results demonstrate that EEG-ConvTransformer achieves improved classification accuracy over the state-of-the-art techniques across five different visual stimuli classification tasks. Finally, quantitative analysis of inter-head diversity also shows low similarity in representational subspaces, emphasizing the implicit diversity of multi-head attention.
The Partial Least Square Regression (PLSR) exhibits admirable competence for predicting continuous variables from inter-correlated brain recordings in the brain-computer interface. However, PLSR is in essence formulated based on the least square criterion, thus, being non-robust with respect to noises. The aim of this study is to propose a new robust implementation for PLSR. To this end, the maximum correntropy criterion (MCC) is used to propose a new robust variant of PLSR, called as Partial Maximum Correntropy Regression (PMCR). The half-quadratic optimization is utilized to calculate the robust projectors for the dimensionality reduction, and the regression coefficients are optimized by a fixed-point approach. We evaluate the proposed PMCR with a synthetic example and the public Neurotycho electrocorticography (ECoG) datasets. The extensive experimental results demonstrate that, the proposed PMCR can achieve better prediction performance than the conventional PLSR and existing variants with three different performance indicators in high-dimensional and noisy regression tasks. PMCR can suppress the performance degradation caused by the adverse noise, ameliorating the decoding robustness of the brain-computer interface.
At present, people usually use some methods based on convolutional neural networks (CNNs) for Electroencephalograph (EEG) decoding. However, CNNs have limitations in perceiving global dependencies, which is not adequate for common EEG paradigms with a strong overall relationship. Regarding this issue, we propose a novel EEG decoding method that mainly relies on the attention mechanism. The EEG data is firstly preprocessed and spatially filtered. And then, we apply attention transforming on the feature-channel dimension so that the model can enhance more relevant spatial features. The most crucial step is to slice the data in the time dimension for attention transforming, and finally obtain a highly distinguishable representation. At this time, global averaging pooling and a simple fully-connected layer are used to classify different categories of EEG data. Experiments on two public datasets indicate that the strategy of attention transforming effectively utilizes spatial and temporal features. And we have reached the level of the state-of-the-art in multi-classification of EEG, with fewer parameters. As far as we know, it is the first time that a detailed and complete method based on the transformer idea has been proposed in this field. It has good potential to promote the practicality of brain-computer interface (BCI). The source code can be found at: \textit{https://github.com/anranknight/EEG-Transformer}.
This work proposes a hybrid Brain Computer Interface system for the automation of a wheelchair for the disabled. Herein a working prototype of a BCI-based wheelchair is detailed that can navigate inside a typical home environment with minimum structural modification and without any visual obstruction and discomfort to the user. The prototype is based on a combined mechanism of steady-state visually evoked potential and eye blinks. To elicit SSVEP, LEDs flickering at 13Hz and 15Hz were used to select the left and right direction, respectively, and EEG data was recorded. In addition, the occurrence of three continuous blinks was used as an indicator for stopping an ongoing action. The wavelet packet denoising method was applied, followed by feature extraction methods such as Wavelet Packet Decomposition and Canonical Correlation Analysis over narrowband reconstructed EEG signals. Bayesian optimization was used to obtain 5 fold cross-validations to optimize the hyperparameters of the Support Vector Machine. The resulting new model was tested and the average cross-validation accuracy 89.65% + 6.6% (SD) and testing accuracy 83.53% + 8.59% (SD) were obtained. The wheelchair was controlled by RaspberryPi through WiFi. The developed prototype demonstrated an average of 86.97% success rate for all trials with 4.015s for each command execution. The prototype can be used efficiently in a home environment without causing any discomfort to the user.
Brain-computer interface (BCI) is used for communication between humans and devices by recognizing status and intention of humans. Communication between humans and a drone using electroencephalogram (EEG) signals is one of the most challenging issues in the BCI domain. In particular, the control of drone swarms (the direction and formation) has more advantages compared to the control of a drone. The visual imagery (VI) paradigm is that subjects visually imagine specific objects or scenes. Reduction of the variability among EEG signals of subjects is essential for practical BCI-based systems. In this study, we proposed the subepoch-wise feature encoder (SEFE) to improve the performances in the subject-independent tasks by using the VI dataset. This study is the first attempt to demonstrate the possibility of generalization among subjects in the VI-based BCI. We used the leave-one-subject-out cross-validation for evaluating the performances. We obtained higher performances when including our proposed module than excluding our proposed module. The DeepConvNet with SEFE showed the highest performance of 0.72 among six different decoding models. Hence, we demonstrated the feasibility of decoding the VI dataset in the subject-independent task with robust performances by using our proposed module.
The brain computer interface (BCI) systems are utilized for transferring information among humans and computers by analyzing electroencephalogram (EEG) recordings.The process of mentally previewing a motor movement without generating the corporal output can be described as motor imagery (MI).In this emerging research field, the number of commands is also limited in relation to the number of MI tasks; in the current literature, mostly two or four commands (classes) are studied. As a solution to this problem, it is recommended to use mental tasks as well as MI tasks. Unfortunately, the use of this approach reduces the classification performance of MI EEG signals. The fMRI analyses show that the resources in the brain associated with the motor imagery can be activated independently. It is assumed that the brain activity induced by the MI of the combination of body parts corresponds to the superposition of the activities generated during each body parts's simple MI. In this study, in order to create more than four BCI commands, we suggest to generate combined MI EEG signals artificially by using left hand, right hand, tongue, and feet motor imageries in pairs. A maximum of ten different BCI commands can be generated by using four motor imageries in pairs.This study aims to achieve high classification performances for BCI commands produced from four motor imageries by implementing a small-sized deep neural network (DNN).The presented method is evaluated on the four-class datasets of BCI Competitions III and IV, and an average classification performance of 81.8% is achieved for ten classes. The above assumption is also validated on a different dataset which consists of simple and combined MI EEG signals acquired in real time. Trained with the artificially generated combined MI EEG signals, DivFE resulted in an average of 76.5% success rate for the combined MI EEG signals acquired in real-time.
Epilepsy is a disorder of the brain denoted by frequent seizures. The symptoms of seizure include confusion, abnormal staring, and rapid, sudden, and uncontrollable hand movements. Epileptic seizure detection methods involve neurological exams, blood tests, neuropsychological tests, and neuroimaging modalities. Among these, neuroimaging modalities have received considerable attention from specialist physicians. One method to facilitate the accurate and fast diagnosis of epileptic seizures is to employ computer-aided diagnosis systems (CADS) based on deep learning (DL) and neuroimaging modalities. This paper has studied a comprehensive overview of DL methods employed for epileptic seizures detection and prediction using neuroimaging modalities. First, DL-based CADS for epileptic seizures detection and prediction using neuroimaging modalities are discussed. Also, descriptions of various datasets, preprocessing algorithms, and DL models which have been used for epileptic seizures detection and prediction have been included. Then, research on rehabilitation tools has been presented, which contains brain-computer interface (BCI), cloud computing, internet of things (IoT), hardware implementation of DL techniques on field-programmable gate array (FPGA), etc. In the discussion section, a comparison has been carried out between research on epileptic seizure detection and prediction. The challenges in epileptic seizures detection and prediction using neuroimaging modalities and DL models have been described. In addition, possible directions for future works in this field, specifically for solving challenges in datasets, DL, rehabilitation, and hardware models, have been proposed. The final section is dedicated to the conclusion which summarizes the significant findings of the paper.
Motor imagery (MI)-based brain-computer interface (BCI) systems are being increasingly employed to provide alternative means of communication and control for people suffering from neuro-motor impairments, with a special effort to bring these systems out of the controlled lab environments. Hence, accurately classifying MI from brain signals, e.g., from electroencephalography (EEG), is essential to obtain reliable BCI systems. However, MI classification is still a challenging task, because the signals are characterized by poor SNR, high intra-subject and cross-subject variability. Deep learning approaches have started to emerge as valid alternatives to standard machine learning techniques, e.g., filter bank common spatial pattern (FBCSP), to extract subject-independent features and to increase the cross-subject classification performance of MI BCI systems. In this paper, we first present a review of the most recent studies using deep learning for MI classification, with particular attention to their cross-subject performance. Second, we propose DynamicNet, a Python-based tool for quick and flexible implementations of deep learning models based on convolutional neural networks. We show-case the potentiality of DynamicNet by implementing EEGNet, a well-established architecture for effective EEG classification. Finally, we compare its performance with FBCSP in a 4-class MI classification over public datasets. To explore its cross-subject classification ability, we applied three different cross-validation schemes. From our results, we demonstrate that DynamicNet-implemented EEGNet outperforms FBCSP by about 25%, with a statistically significant difference when cross-subject validation schemes are applied.
An asynchronous Brain--Computer Interface (BCI) based on imagined speech is a tool that allows to control an external device or to emit a message at the moment the user desires to by decoding EEG signals of imagined speech. In order to correctly implement these types of BCI, we must be able to detect from a continuous signal, when the subject starts to imagine words. In this work, five methods of feature extraction based on wavelet decomposition, empirical mode decomposition, frequency energies, fractal dimension and chaos theory features are presented to solve the task of detecting imagined words segments from continuous EEG signals as a preliminary study for a latter implementation of an asynchronous BCI based on imagined speech. These methods are tested in three datasets using four different classifiers and the higher F1 scores obtained are 0.73, 0.79, and 0.68 for each dataset, respectively. This results are promising to build a system that automatizes the segmentation of imagined words segments for latter classification.
Neuropsychological studies suggest that co-operative activities among different brain functional areas drive high-level cognitive processes. To learn the brain activities within and among different functional areas of the brain, we propose LGGNet, a novel neurologically inspired graph neural network, to learn local-global-graph representations of electroencephalography (EEG) for Brain-Computer Interface (BCI). The input layer of LGGNet comprises a series of temporal convolutions with multi-scale 1D convolutional kernels and kernel-level attentive fusion. It captures temporal dynamics of EEG which then serves as input to the proposed local and global graph-filtering layers. Using a defined neurophysiologically meaningful set of local and global graphs, LGGNet models the complex relations within and among functional areas of the brain. Under the robust nested cross-validation settings, the proposed method is evaluated on three publicly available datasets for four types of cognitive classification tasks, namely, the attention, fatigue, emotion, and preference classification tasks. LGGNet is compared with state-of-the-art methods, such as DeepConvNet, EEGNet, R2G-STNN, TSception, RGNN, AMCNN-DGCN, HRNN and GraphNet. The results show that LGGNet outperforms these methods, and the improvements are statistically significant (p<0.05) in most cases. The results show that bringing neuroscience prior knowledge into neural network design yields an improvement of classification performance. The source code can be found at https://github.com/yi-ding-cs/LGG
Many studies have explored brain signals during the performance of a memory task to predict later remembered items. However, prediction methods are still poorly used in real life and are not practical due to the use of electroencephalography (EEG) recorded from the scalp. Ear-EEG has been recently used to measure brain signals due to its flexibility when applying it to real world environments. In this study, we attempt to predict whether a shown stimulus is going to be remembered or forgotten using ear-EEG and compared its performance with scalp-EEG. Our results showed that there was no significant difference between ear-EEG and scalp-EEG. In addition, the higher prediction accuracy was obtained using a convolutional neural network (pre-stimulus: 74.06%, on-going stimulus: 69.53%) and it was compared to other baseline methods. These results showed that it is possible to predict performance of a memory task using ear-EEG signals and it could be used for predicting memory retrieval in a practical brain-computer interface.
In this study, an advanced CCA-based algorithn called hybrid template canonical correlation analysis (HTCCA) was proposed to improve the performance of brain-computer interface (BCI) based on steady state visual evoked potential (SSVEP) uuder data-linited condition. The HTCCA method combines the training data from several subjects to construct SSVEP templates. The experinental results evaluated on two public benchmark datasets showed that the proposed method outperforms the compared methods in both detection accuracy and information transfer rate when the number of tuials is small.Considering that user-friendly experience will become a key factor for BCI in practical application, it is very necessary to develop effective methods based on limited EEG samples. This study demonstrates that the proposed method has great potential in the application of SSVEP-based brain-computer interfaces.
Mental task identification and classification using single/limited channel(s) electroencephalogram (EEG) signals in real-time play an important role in the design of portable brain-computer interface (BCI) and neurofeedback (NFB) systems. However, the real-time recorded EEG signals are often contaminated with noises such as ocular artifacts (OAs) and muscle artifacts (MAs), which deteriorate the hand-crafted features extracted from EEG signal, resulting inadequate identification and classification of mental tasks. Therefore, we investigate the use of recent deep learning techniques which do not require any manual feature extraction or artifact suppression step. In this paper, we propose a light-weight one-dimensional convolutional neural network (1D-CNN) architecture for mental task identification and classification. The robustness of the proposed architecture is evaluated using artifact-free and artifact-contaminated EEG signals taken from two publicly available databases (i.e, Keirn and Aunon ($K$) database and EEGMAT ($E$) database) and in-house ($R$) database recorded using single-channel neurosky mindwave mobile 2 (MWM2) EEG headset in performing not only mental/non-mental binary task classification but also different mental/mental multi-tasks classification. Evaluation results demonstrate that the proposed architecture achieves the highest subject-independent classification accuracy of $99.7\%$ and $100\%$ for multi-class classification and pair-wise mental tasks classification respectively in database $K$. Further, the proposed architecture achieves subject-independent classification accuracy of $99\%$ and $98\%$ in database $E$ and the recorded database $R$ respectively. Comparative performance analysis demonstrates that the proposed architecture outperforms existing approaches not only in terms of classification accuracy but also in robustness against artifacts.
Classification of cognitive workload promises immense benefit in diverse areas ranging from driver safety to augmenting human capability through closed loop brain computer interface. The brain is the most metabolically active organ in the body and increases its metabolic activity and thus oxygen consumption with increasing cognitive demand. In this study, we explore the feasibility of in-ear SpO2 cognitive workload tracking. To this end, we preform cognitive workload assessment in 8 subjects, based on an N-back task, whereby the subjects are asked to count and remember the number of odd numbers displayed on a screen in 5 second windows. The 2 and 3-back tasks lead to either the lowest median absolute SpO2 or largest median decrease in SpO2 in all of the subjects, indicating a robust and measurable decrease in blood oxygen in response to increased cognitive workload. Using features derived from in-ear pulse oximetry, including SpO2, pulse rate and respiration rate, we were able to classify the 4 N-back task categories, over 5 second epochs, with a mean accuracy of 94.2%. Moreover, out of 21 total features, the 9 most important features for classification accuracy were all SpO2 related features. The findings suggest that in-ear SpO2 measurements provide valuable information for classification of cognitive workload over short time windows, which together with the small form factor promises a new avenue for real time cognitive workload tracking.
Vigilance of an operator is compromised in performing many monotonous activities like workshop and manufacturing floor tasks, driving, night shift workers, flying, and in general any activity which requires keen attention of an individual over prolonged periods of time. Driver or operator fatigue in these situations leads to drowsiness and lowered vigilance which is one of the largest contributors to injuries and fatalities amongst road accidents or workshop floor accidents. Having a vigilance monitoring system to detect drop in vigilance in these situations becomes very important. This paper presents a system which uses non-invasively recorded Frontal EEG from an easy-to-use commercially available Brain Computer Interface wearable device to determine the vigilance state of an individual. The change in the power spectrum in the Frontal Theta Band (4-8Hz) of an individual's brain wave predicts the changes in the attention level of an individual - providing an early detection and warning system. This method provides an accurate, yet cheap and practical system for vigilance monitoring across different environments.
Lack of adequate training samples and noisy high-dimensional features are key challenges faced by Motor Imagery (MI) decoding algorithms for electroencephalogram (EEG) based Brain-Computer Interface (BCI). To address these challenges, inspired from neuro-physiological signatures of MI, this paper proposes a novel Filter-Bank Convolutional Network (FBCNet) for MI classification. FBCNet employs a multi-view data representation followed by spatial filtering to extract spectro-spatially discriminative features. This multistage approach enables efficient training of the network even when limited training data is available. More significantly, in FBCNet, we propose a novel Variance layer that effectively aggregates the EEG time-domain information. With this design, we compare FBCNet with state-of-the-art (SOTA) BCI algorithm on four MI datasets: The BCI competition IV dataset 2a (BCIC-IV-2a), the OpenBMI dataset, and two large datasets from chronic stroke patients. The results show that, by achieving 76.20% 4-class classification accuracy, FBCNet sets a new SOTA for BCIC-IV-2a dataset. On the other three datasets, FBCNet yields up to 8% higher binary classification accuracies. Additionally, using explainable AI techniques we present one of the first reports about the differences in discriminative EEG features between healthy subjects and stroke patients. Also, the FBCNet source code is available at https://github.com/ravikiran-mane/FBCNet.
Brain-computer interface (BCI) systems are usually designed specifically for each subject based on motor imagery. Therefore, the usability of these networks has become a significant challenge. The network has to be designed separately for each user, which is time-consuming for the user. Therefore, this study proposes a method by which the calibration time is significantly reduced while the classification accuracy is increased. In this method, we calibrated the features extracted from the motor imagery task by dividing the features extracted from the resting-state into both open-eye and closed-eye modes and the state in which the subject moves his eyes. The best classification accuracy was obtained using the SVM classifier using the resting-state signal in the open eye, which increased by 3.64% to 74.04%. In this paper, we also investigated the effect of recording time of the resting-state signal and the impact of eye state on the classification accuracy.